![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
Bubble, bubble, toil and trouble
Sep. 19th, 2020 01:31 pmIn mid-June, just BEFORE school would normally have ended for the summer, the Ontario government rolled out a document explaining how you can build your very own "social circle" of nearest-and- dearest, or perhaps nearest-by-necessity of up to ten people, where direct physical contact is allowed and masking and physical distancing are not required. In other provinces, these are widely referred to as your "bubble". I wrote about it here on June 15 and provided a link to the Ontario government document but if you want to refresh your memory, here is that link again:
https://files.ontario.ca/moh-how-to-build-your-social-circle-en-2020-06-12.pdf
As kids return to school, many of those who DID diligently obey all the rules and build their government-sanctioned bubbles are now finding those bubbles burst by the very government who dictated the rules in the first place!
In-person schooling typically involves "cohorts" of students all in one particular grade. Is there a difference between a cohort and a bubble? Well, yes... you don't necessarily hug or even shake hands with everyone in your class or your school. Playground games have been drastically limited as have normal school activities like singing and playing certain instruments in an ensemble. But class sizes haven't been reduced and over the past months, clear distinctions have been drawn as well between indoor and outdoor interactions.
So who precisely can benefit from "bubbling" without breaking any rules? I suppose a few people or maybe couples who happen to live alone (and likely within the same part of town) could bubble together if they don't already have any living relatives, intimate partners, personal attendants, or friends of a highly tactile nature. But I'm having a hard time imagining a legitimate 10-person bubble unless maybe it's a family of 10, a commune of folks living off the land, maybe a kibbutz...
It all comes down to that Rule no. 5 - be true to your circle. I mean, I'm really just in a bubble of two at the moment. You'd think there'd be plenty of room for growth and development there. We'd add our daughter's family of five in a heartbeat... except that that would be totally unfair and impractical for each and every one of them. I mean, they're bound to need babysitters or other child care workers and then they have their own friends and bandmates and the grandchildren have friends and playmates and other grandparents, aunts, uncles, cousins and on it goes...
Add school into the mix and is it any wonder that harried parents everywhere are throwing up their hands in despair?
I know this is a new virus and it's inevitable that to some extent we have to learn as we go. The novel "Coronavirus!" is still being written. But surely some of this could still have been planned a little better even if those plans had to be tweaked, adjusted and modified by a sort of calculated trial and error method. We can't all be flying by the seat of our pants all of the time without crashing spectacularly!
https://files.ontario.ca/moh-how-to-build-your-social-circle-en-2020-06-12.pdf
As kids return to school, many of those who DID diligently obey all the rules and build their government-sanctioned bubbles are now finding those bubbles burst by the very government who dictated the rules in the first place!
In-person schooling typically involves "cohorts" of students all in one particular grade. Is there a difference between a cohort and a bubble? Well, yes... you don't necessarily hug or even shake hands with everyone in your class or your school. Playground games have been drastically limited as have normal school activities like singing and playing certain instruments in an ensemble. But class sizes haven't been reduced and over the past months, clear distinctions have been drawn as well between indoor and outdoor interactions.
So who precisely can benefit from "bubbling" without breaking any rules? I suppose a few people or maybe couples who happen to live alone (and likely within the same part of town) could bubble together if they don't already have any living relatives, intimate partners, personal attendants, or friends of a highly tactile nature. But I'm having a hard time imagining a legitimate 10-person bubble unless maybe it's a family of 10, a commune of folks living off the land, maybe a kibbutz...
It all comes down to that Rule no. 5 - be true to your circle. I mean, I'm really just in a bubble of two at the moment. You'd think there'd be plenty of room for growth and development there. We'd add our daughter's family of five in a heartbeat... except that that would be totally unfair and impractical for each and every one of them. I mean, they're bound to need babysitters or other child care workers and then they have their own friends and bandmates and the grandchildren have friends and playmates and other grandparents, aunts, uncles, cousins and on it goes...
Add school into the mix and is it any wonder that harried parents everywhere are throwing up their hands in despair?
I know this is a new virus and it's inevitable that to some extent we have to learn as we go. The novel "Coronavirus!" is still being written. But surely some of this could still have been planned a little better even if those plans had to be tweaked, adjusted and modified by a sort of calculated trial and error method. We can't all be flying by the seat of our pants all of the time without crashing spectacularly!
